Thursday, July 24, 2014

Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC

After reviewing the Franklin-Christoph Model 02 Intrinsic Smoke & Ice fountain pen in broad, I knew I had to investigate this adorable pocket version. Fortunately, I had won a $100 gift certificate to Franklin-Christoph's online store a little while ago (a great reason to like their Facebook page!), so I used it to get this Model 40P and I upgraded the nib to a Masuyama broad stub. Thank you to Franklin-Christoph for that great giveaway!
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
ABOUT

Body Material: Acrylic
Trim: None
Length (capped): 4.22"
Length (uncapped nib-end): 3.81"
Length (posted): 5.22"
Barrel Diameter: 0.50"
Section Diameter: 0.41"
Nib material: Steel
Weight: 14 g
Fill type: Cartridge/Eyedropper
Price: $134.50USD (with Masuyama nib)
Where to buy: Franklin-Christoph

PACKAGING

Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Just like its "big brother" the Model 02 Intrinsic, the Model 40 Pocket arrived in the same simple box: a simple hard black case with a striped finish across it. The inside is satin-lined, the pen held in place on a felt bed with a satin loop. It comes with the pen, a converter, cartridges so you can ink up right away, along with some Franklin-Christoph cards. Nice, simple packaging. No wasted space. I like that.

APPEARANCE
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
The Model 40P fountain pen is gorgeous. This is really a compact version of the Model 02 Intrinsic Smoke & Ice. The cap appears full-sized and threads deeply on to the barrel. The cap and barrel have the icy motif body. It looks like...well...ice. The top of the cap has a coloured acrylic plug: both deeply shimmery and pearlescent; I love it. I have one of each cap: the fire and the smoke. The fire is swirly and hot red, and the smoke is sultry and deep grey.
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
The end of the barrel tapers to accommodate being posted and is a polished clear acrylic. The threads are located at the top of the section, unlike the Model 02 Intrinsic.
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
NIB & PERFORMANCE
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
The nib is aesthetically pleasing; a good size for the pen and the colour scheme all matches. It seems to be a #5 stainless steel, although you can also upgrade to a gold nib should you wish. Honestly though, get a Masuyama grind and you'll never think about a gold nib again.

I had heard that Mike Masuyama is a master at nib grinding, so I was really looking forward to giving this broad stub Masuyama grind a run. I didn't flush the pen, just inked it up immediately. ... And I picked one of the sludgiest, driest inks I have: J. Herbin's Rouge Hematite. I must admit I was a little surprised to find this nib so smooth and so juicy that it handled Rouge Hematite, usually a dry and clumpy ink, with ease. The nib puts down a wet line of ink that shades beautifully, shows off the ink's sheen easily, and the nib's line variation is easy to enjoy. Excellent performance.
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
While the nib was very smooth and handled the ink well, I was expecting a more stubby grind though. I have also used a Masuyama medium cursive italic and I think I was hoping for that kind of variation from it. I'm not disappointed by the performance, it just wasn't what I was expecting. If you're looking for a sharper grind with more crisp and precise variation, go for a medium or broad cursive italic grind. A stub will be softer and smoother though, if you are new to this world.

IN HAND
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
The threads are located quite high up the section, so although they are a little sharp, they shouldn't get in the way of your writing. The pen is light and comfortable for me to hold, and I can actually write without it posted, though when it's posted, it is more comfy, although it must be posted deeply because the lid can wiggle off. As it is light and well-balanced, there's no need to death grip the whole thing, so the threads really shouldn't be an issue.
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
On desk, if you go clipless, be aware your pen can roll away!

PROS & CONS
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC


Side note: I completely forgot about this when I wrote this list: the cap posts but just by friction, so if not posted deeply/tightly enough, it can fall off.

OVERALL
Review: Franklin-Christoph Model 40P Fountain Pen - Masuyama Broad Stub @1901FC
I really enjoy this pen. It's a very cute size, comfortable, lightweight, very attractive, and the nib is very smooth and enjoyable. As I said, it's not as crisp and variable as I was hoping for (but clearly a stub is not the same as a cursive italic!), but that doesn't mean it doesn't perform well! Simply put: highly recommended. Get a Masuyama grind, turn the pen into an eyedropper, and fall in love with this thing. Totally worth it. Just don't lose your cap.

FOLLOW FRANKLIN-CHRISTOPH
Browse
Join Client List
Facebook
Twitter

16 comments:

Fountain Pen Day said...

Fantastic review of a pen I want so much, especially with Masuyama nib upgrade. Excellent pictures as well. Thanks for taking the time to put this review out there.

youstruckgold said...

Excellent review. Not sure if the pen is for me; but I love FC's generally and as for Mike... hero!

NoFuture NoHope said...

Can't use eyedroppers :((. My hands are to worm and the pens start leaking when there is too much air in the body :((

Azizah Asgarali said...

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed :)

Azizah Asgarali said...

Thank you :) YESSS sooo wish I had gotten the cursive italic... next one. MUAHAHA.

Azizah Asgarali said...

Ah, that's probably not to do with the heat of your hands but just leaking from the threads. Have you tried putting a little bit of silicone grease on the threads before you seal the body?

Keith McCleary said...

I've been wanting one for some time now, but they've been out of stock for more than a month. I bought a 1.1 mm cursive italic #5 from them to replace a plain jane IPG nib in a custom pen my wife bought me for my birthday and I love it.

NoFuture NoHope said...

The pen leaks through the nib and only if there is more air than ink in the body. I am of course using rubber o-rings and silicone grease, but that did not help :(

Azizah Asgarali said...

OH! I was thinking it leaked from the barrel. Sorry. I see what you mean. :(

Azizah Asgarali said...

It is fairly thick, so it might be safe from blorping ink - especially compared to pens like the Pilot Petit1.

Azizah Asgarali said...

Yes, true, they have a hard time keeping these ones in stock! Excellent choice on the cursive italic too, that's just a fantastic nib.

bobcorrigan said...

Ordered my 40p Fire and ice with a Masuyaa nib at the start of last week, and it arrived on Saturday!!

Azizah Asgarali said...

Beautiful! What nib are you getting?

bobcorrigan said...

Medium stub. It is ground to ~0.9mm so it should be a fine, expressive line. It is a gift so it has not been inked yet:)

i-style said...

Hello Azizah,
you mention with posting the cap it can wiggle loose. How much is that an issue/the case? And did you hear that from other 40-users as well? SBRE-B does mention that issue also.
This is kind of an turn off for me from a pen that is otherwise very atractive!

Thanks for your answer in advance.

Azizah Asgarali said...

I'm not sure about other users, sorry. I don't often write with my pens posted so it hasn't been much of a long standing issue for me, fortunately.

Post a Comment

Please Share!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
 
Creative Commons License
GourmetPens by Azizah Asgarali is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at http://www.gourmetpens.com.